I have three ideas so let me know which one you all like!

Stealing Home
Anna Marchetti has a plan for high school, find true friends, make the top then list, make a varsity sport and find the perfect boyfriend. Everything's going in the right direction, she finds friends, she makes varsity softball and then theres John. Perfect John. But there's one thing that stands in the way of her chances with John. John's "best friend" Caroline Cullinane. They say they're "just friends" but Anna isn't convinced. But Anna does know John is meant to be hers and if that means getting Caroline out of the way so be it.

Golden Boy
Brooklyn Hamilton wants nothing to do with baseball. Well morely her high school baseball team. To be more exact her ex Vinny Carlson. She wants to nothing to do with him, but lately it seems like he's everywhere. He's inviading everything that she felt to be once hers. She'll do anything to avoid him but how do you escape the school's Golden Boy?
Vinny Carlson is the the Golden Boy at his high school. He's got everything he could ever want, the coolest best friend ever, a sweet ride, college offers left and right with baseball scholarships. Well there is one thing missing. The girl of his dreams wants nothing to do with him. Vinny may be the the Golden Boy but can he survive a potential broken heart?

-Title Goes Here-
Shane Craft is a junior who flew under the radar the first two years of high school, despite the fact his twin sister Brianna Craft is as the top of the popularity chain. But then new student Hayley Flannery shows up and threathens Brianna's top spot. Hayley isn't interested in Brianna's throne, but she is interested in her brother. Shane's never had a girlfriend but the feeling towards Hayley is mutual. But in the Craft household Hayley is public enemy number one and if Brianna hates someone Shane is supposed to, to. But how can he hate public enemy number one when she's that pretty?
*open to title suggestions for this one