Madi_Milkshakes* · 9 years ago
I can't believe people say they can't sing. I mean come on, what did they ever do to you people!? There's always those people who criticise the poor lads and give them hate and all that bull-crud when it's completely rude and unnecessary. It's fine if you don't like them but don't go hating and dissing because there's plenty of people who do like them. If you don't have anything nice to say, please introduce your bottom lip with your top lip and please be quiet! If One Direction use auto tune then how come they sound so fricking awesome in live concert? Answer me that? It makes me sick how people judge them. They're genuine people that does have a high job than most people. How would you feel if someone said you suck at something you absolutely love doing?
0 reply

GameofThrones · 1 decade ago
We are not saying they can't sing, everybody can sing. No, no.. We are just saying they are terrible at it.
0 reply

rebecca* · 1 decade ago
You don't have to be good at singing to know if someone else isn't good.
Like, I think most people would agree Ke$ha's voice is terrible, even if some of us are even worse.
I mean, I don't think they're terrible singers but I also don't think they're all that fantastic.
I don't have to be a successful singer to have that opinion.
0 reply

hockeyprincess11 · 1 decade ago
Guys, for one thing.. EVERYONE is auto tuned on the radio. One direction DOES sing live for concerts. I'll tell you how good they were after the concert tomorrow(: Stop hating just because your life isn't going to be filled with more achievements than them. They are good and down to earth people. So stop and grow up.
0 reply

LilSuperstar · 1 decade ago
@EllaAtTheDisco well when they were on the x-factor there was no auto tune they had to sing live ,and they were pretty amazing.
Just saying
0 reply

zyxwME4754 · 1 decade ago
VVV You kind of did though.
0 reply

OneDirectionQuotes · 1 decade ago
People,
I didn't ask you to write your whole life story on this quote. But thanks anyways. :) xx
0 reply

EllaAtTheDisco · 1 decade ago
One Direction can't sing. I'm sorry, but they're all autotune. Also, I start my first year going to a performing arts school on scholarship for my singing and guitar playing in August, thanks for asking. Also, Hey, guys, what happened to that Bieber kid that was so famous this time last year? No one cares about him because they realized how terrible he actually is. Just because some family is rich enough to get their kids signed on a big label and pay for all the stuff a regular, good band has to earn. I was just stating my opinion on them, though. Chill out. And yes, I said something about them using auto-tune. Because they do. Auto-tune is fine until it gets to the point where you can hear only the auto-tune drowning out their vocals. I remember when musicians were just raw singers. What happened to the bands like, Rise Against, A Day To Remember, All Time Low, Panic! At The Disco, Avenged Sevenfold, Sleeping With Sirens, Cute Is What We Aim For, Cartel, Parachute, and Never Shout Never. What about the older stuff too? Pearl Jam, Sublime, Social Disortion, and Stone Sour. Honestly, those are good musicians. In my opinion at least. Raw vocals, and barely any autotune. Not recorded in a studio and lip synced on stage with stupid dance moves. What honestly happened to music. Is it seriously fun to watch 5 guys lip sync and dance poorly in a stadium? I'd pick mosh-pits, and crowd surfing anyday. Raw Vocals > Lip Syncing. Just saying guys.
0 reply

xMoments · 1 decade ago
auto-tune?

so weird how they was amazing on x factor, and there was not auto-tune then
they had to sing live

and i'm pretty sure every singer uses autotune, they're not perfect singers :P
0 reply

Wildthing_at_heart · 1 decade ago
;)lol.
0 reply

StardollUnicorn01 · 1 decade ago
Lol. Guys. First of all, Rebecca Black got famous for being an idiot and sucking at music.

They barely use auto tune.


If they used auto tune, sucked at singing, the wouldn't have gotten together on the X-Factor, or a nominee for a BRIT AWARD.

Now, my explanation is done. I can't hear anything other than the 40,000 FANS SCREAMING AT THEIR CONCERTS!
0 reply

TheLonelyMarshmallow · 1 decade ago
Honestly guys, calm down witty is where people come to express their opinion. If people want to say their hatred about one direction, let them. Their not doing it to hurt you......
0 reply

Breeze · 1 decade ago
I've never said that One Direction can't sing but I've been thinking about the "tell me more about your music career"... Take Rebecca Black for instance. A LOT of people say she can't sing. Most of them don't have music careers so...... ....?
0 reply

Temptress · 1 decade ago
saying that is like saying i can't tell anyone that they're talented at writing because i'm pretty good at writing too
just because i can't sing doesn't mean that i automatically have to be of the opinion that everyone in the world is talented except me
0 reply

dancergrl101 · 1 decade ago
I KNOW RIGHT? My friend was all like, "One Direction is hot but they can't sing at all!" Oh let's see, HE didn't even auditionnfor the school musical, let alone X Factor, and the last time I checked, he's not world famous.
0 reply

morodz · 1 decade ago
you said tut just cz u luv 1D 'n they're the best 4 u ,look i don't hate 'em i just prefrer othres like Outlandish band , kenza farah......
0 reply

Edith170 · 1 decade ago
They're good singers but I just don't like them....Please don't take this as an insult Its just my own honest opinion
0 reply

radiancewithin · 1 decade ago
you don't need to know how to sing to know if someone's good or not. btw, been playing the flute and piccolo for 5 years. thanks.
0 reply

pichimartintovar · 1 decade ago
currently not active.. But its a shane that the world is missing out on such a beautiful voice.. lol jk I suck too
0 reply

briiitttttttany · 1 decade ago
lol i don't thing 1d can sing, they have no talent in singing at all. just because they can't sing, doesn't mean i can. lol. "directioners" get so butthurt over someone's opinion.
0 reply