Girlfriend's Best Friend
CHAPTER 16 x x x .
A month had passed and I was still happily in a relationship with Kelli. I was only seventeen—I’d never really been in love before, but I think I loved Kelli. Like, really loved her.
I trusted her completely with anything and everything, and what I loved is that she didn’t get mad, upset, or jealous when I talked to another girl—only Brooke, which was understandable, especially after what Carter had told her that one time.
We only hung out without Brooke occasionally because Kelli didn’t want her there, and this was one of those times when she wasn’t there.
“Yo, why can’t we just invite Brooke? She’s so fun to be around,” Carter had said.
“I don’t want her here,” Kelli said honestly. “It’s great getting to talk to you guys without her all over you, flirting and trying to hook up.”
“It’s great getting to talk to Cody too without you doing that but I guess we can’t all get what we want,” Carter said. Kelli shut up really fast.
“She’s just really selfish with attention. It always has to be on her,” Kelli tried to explain.
“I think the problem is that you really wanted to hook up with me but now you can’t because Brooke did. That’s kind of what Cody did—went after you because he couldn’t go after Brooke after I did,” Carter laughed.
“What?” she said angrily, a thin layer of tears forming over her eyes.
“You didn’t tell her you liked Brooke first?” Carter laughed, thinking he was funny.
“WHAT?” she started bawling. “You’re dating me because you didn’t get to Brooke first?”
“Carter, you didn’t get to her first, you just kissed her first,” Mattie said. “I actually hooked up with her.”
“I hooked up with her too, bro. So did Jace,” Carter said. Mattie turned to him, angrily, “Bro, what the f.uck, she was mine first!”
“You never even asked her out, and besides, she wanted to get with me. Graham hooked up with her too!” Jace said.
“Jace! I only told you, why would you tell everyone else?” Graham yelled.
“Yo, stop yelling at Jace,” Duke defended him. “You told me, too.”
“Only after you told me that you hooked up with her!” Graham fought back.
“Well she blew me so I’m winning,” Carter bragged. The guys kept fighting that they all got with her, and for a second I thought I’d have to step in so that they didn’t all beat each other up.
“That’s why I chose you. You’re not a sl.ut like Brooke,” I tried to look better, but I just ended up making myself look worse.
“You still liked her,” Kelli cried as she got off my lap and walked off quickly. I went after her, and after days of her ignoring all my texts, calls, and even the old fashioned throwing rocks at her window, she finally forgave me. As for the guys, they agreed not to get with Brooke anymore because they were too good of friends to let someone like her get in between them.
Everything was back to normal, but nothing could have prepared me for what was about to change.
Note: uh oh